Brucehankins I've never really tried window tiling managers as such.
But Garuda GNOME was my favorite Arch distro up until their kernel had issues with pulse audio on Gnome making the wifi toggle inaccessible. I tried Garuda Dragonised Gamer Ultimate edition 5 days back and it was such a kitchen sink distro that it couldn't even run any game after an initial full upgrade. I haven't tried their normal dragonised edition featuring KDE yet, seems lean. I tried Manjaro LTS and minimal then and it just straight out wouldn't even install libre office because pulse audio had some dependencies that had to be edited and built. Now, I'm an intermediate skilled linux user, but if a distro can't install libre office because of some dependency issues, that distro clearly sucks and I've seen Manjaro GNOME in better days. I then went to Artix which is vanilla Arch without systemd and it's an awesome distro, but gnome was such a pain there too! Then to Fedora GNOME which was great except for the 2 minute shut down time every single time, atleast they ditched pulse audio and went for pipewire! I wouldn't look at ubuntu or any ubuntu based ditros twice due to ppa s and apt repository messes, I was left where I started: Solus and because budgie for some reason is limited on Solus, I mean they have the new version, but budgie on Arch just has a lot more applets, I tried Manjaro and Garuda with GNOME too and I think their budgie from the AUR has more features!
I was so happy with Solus GNOME, had set up a Windows and Android VM in it, restored all my files finally after a week of Distrohopping in every direction, and now this GNOME is such a pain here too!
I've heard Solus KDE is awesome, the theming looks nice out of the box, I think it's time I say bye to GNOME and hi to Solus KDE,
As much as I've loved GNOME from my very first linux distro of Ubuntu 16/18.04 until Garuda/Fedora March of 2021, it's time to say bye!
KDE Solus, here I come!!!