I use Guayadeque as a player and am very satisfied. Disadvantage is that although he can manage large collections but it is quite slowly. The larger the collection, the longer it takes to start or update the collection after adding new data. But I also have a collection of about 300 GB. But otherwise top.
I'm just as unhappy with Strawbwrry as with the original Clementine since the old mistakes were made, but at least the Taggen now works bit by bit. The sorting of the collection is still questionable.
Sayonara I actually managed but that the global colors are not completely taken over has always bothered me. The orange is always somewhere to see.
Deadbeef is of course unbeatable if you can invest a little bit of time.
In the console I use MOC. CMUS is too complicated with the ShortCuts.
I do not know the other players at all.
greez